Short
and Long Answer Questions
(assignment 19)
Notes:
1) This assignment, like ALL assignments in this class, must be
typed. See handout on class expectations
2)
You MUST use blackboard's digital dropbox (details here)
to submit this homework; if you do not use microsoft word,
be sure to follow these directions
3 ) BE
SURE TO FOLLOW THE FILE-NAMING CONVENTIONS FOR THIS COURSE.
All files should be saved on your computer
as: your last name, followed by an underscore ("_"),
followed by the first two letters of your first name, followed
by an underscore ("_"), followed by the
assignment number. So if a student named Saddam Hussein were to
submit assignment number 19, the file name would be:
hussein_sa_19.doc
THIS
IS ASSIGNMENT 19
This homework
is due at the start of class and can
NOT be turned in late
This homework can NOT
be revised
This homework is worth
2.25% of you final
semester grade, or 225 Fritz Points
How best to answer
these questions? The long answer question #8 requires having read
the entire excerpt, while the short answer questions 1-7 help
guide you along to be able to answer #8.
So, I'd suggest that
you read question #8 first to get a sense of the goal of your
reading, then read the WHOLE excerpt, answering the short-answer
questions as you go along. Then, finally, respond to question
#8, followed by #9.
Understanding
the answer to questions #7 and #9 are essential for an upcoming
assignment; you will NOT be able to answer question #7 unless
you have read pp.
97, 98, and 101 carefully.
I will grade only three of the questions below; I will certainly
grade question #8 (worth 60% of your grade for this assignment)
and then I will choose at random two of the other questions to
grade (together worth 40% of your grade for this assignment).
Any question you do not answer, however, will immediately become
the question second question I grade.
SHORT ANSWER QUESTIONS ON MARKS, "The Industrial
Revolution"
The goal of
these questions is to focus your attention on the author's points
that collectively support his thesis; the answers to these questions
are, accordingly, sign posts for your understanding. Don't pretend
to yourself that you know the answer if you don't; if you can't
answer any one of the short answer questions, you likely won't
be able to answer the "big one" at the end. Think of
these questions as manageably small questions that allow you to
answer the "big one."
Questions
3 and 9 below require knowing and applying a basic economic principle
(Principle 1); answering the extra-credit requires
knowing and applying another principle (Principle 2).
Be
sure you understand these principles!
Principle
1: Core and Periphery.
To
historians and economists who believe in what is know
as "world-systems theory," the system of "core
and periphery" is an inherent feature of
the world economics.
This
theory argues that there is a fundamental division of
labor in the world -- labor is divided between what the
theory calls the core and the periphery:
While the core has a high level of technological
development and manufactures complex or finished products
(in the nineteenth century, that would include fabric,
today it might be computers), the role of the periphery
is to supply raw materials, agricultural products and
cheap labor for the core. Economic exchange
between core and periphery
takes places on unequal terms: The periphery
is forced to sell its products at low prices, but has
to buy the core's products at comparatively
high prices. This unequal state, once established, tends
to continue.
Principle
2: Externalities (skip if you don't
intend to do the extra-credit)
Externalities
are a form of economic side-effects. Externalities are
costs or benefits arising from an economic activity that
affect somebody other than the people engaged in the economic
activity and are not reflected fully in PRICES. For instance,
smoke pumped out by a factory may impose pollution on
nearby residents (a negative externality or a cost); bees
kept to produce honey may pollinate plants belonging to
a nearby farmer, thus boosting his crop (a positive externality
or a benefit).
Another
example: When a fisherman catches a fish and sells it,
that fisherman gets a private benefit -- the revenue from
selling the fish. But there is a cost -- because there
are fewer fish to reproduce, there will be less fish caught
in the next and future years. This cost is spread out
over all the fishermen and consumers of fish, and thus
is "external" to the individual fisherman's
decision how many fish to take. The individual fisherman
does not take into account the influence of his fishing
on the fish that will be available to other fishermen
in the future -- it he isn't going to catch them, why
should he care? The result is that he does not limit his
catch in such a way as to conserve the fish population
to reproduce, and this is why fisheries are overexploited.
|
1)
p. 95 -- what set limits on the world economy before the period
1750 - 1850 and how did it do so?
2)
p. 96 -- what does Marks mean by "conjuncture" in this
context? Do not give me the dictionary definition
-- rather explain how Marks uses this idea in the context of his
argument. Use your own words and only your
own words.
3)
pp. 100 - 101 & 107 - 108 (read these pages carefully)
Two questions:
A) Why
did the author refer to the New World as "a peculiar periphery"?
What was peculiar about it? (Think about the "peculiar
institution" from your questions on the Trans-Atlantic Slave
Trade)
B) How
did this "peculiar periphery" help foster industrialization
in Britain rather than elsewhere? (read 100
- 101 & 107 - 108 carefully
with this question in mind-- the answer is not an immediately
obvious and probably isn't quite what you would assume it is.
Again, keep the term "peculiar periphery" in mind when
answering the question)
4)
pp. 102 - 105 --What does Marks mean when he refers to China pushing
up against the constraints of the "old biological regime"
-- that is, what were the constraints and how was China
pushing up against them?
5) pp. 105 - 107 -- Why were China and
England equally well poised for industrialization in regards to
both the spread of markets and favorable population growth?
This question is a little trickier, because Marks first summarizes
the view of others, and then critiques that view. Don't
get confused between Marks' summary of others and Marks' own analysis.
Be attentive to the framing devices Marks uses to indicate he
is summarizing the interpretations of others.
6) pp. 107 - 109 -- What did England have that
China did not have that mattered for industrialization?
7)
As Marks notes, the British move from adopting an ideology of
protectionism for themselves (that is, slapping tariffs
on foreign goods imported to Britain) to imposing the notion of
free trade and laissez-faire economics
on others (p. 97, 98, 101). According to Marks, how and
why did industrializiation
encourage the British to shift their position? (read
p. 97, 98, 101 carefully -- and keep a copy of this questions
as it will be useful in upcoming assignment regarding the Azamgarb
Proclamation; honestly)
Long Answer Questions
8)
Marks argues against an Euro-centric understanding of
the Industrial Revolution. In response to the question, "Why
did the Industrial Revolution begin in Britain?" this Euro-centric
story-line generally credits some mixture of these three elements:
(1) British inventiveness or scientific spirit, (2) the spread
of markets in Europe, (3) favorable population growth in Europe
as opposed to China. The Euro-centric story-line assumes
both that these three phenomena were what launched the Industrial
Revolution AND that these phenomena were nearly unique to Britain.
Marks
disagrees.
In contrast to the Euro-centric storyline, he argues that the
Industrial Revolution began in Britain (as opposed to elsewhere)
because of historical "conjunctures".
For Marks, what forces converged -- and how -- in a fashion that
fostered the growth of industry in Britain but not in China?
Be sure that your ENTIRE ANSWER is in your
own words. Be sure to explain HOW and WHY the forces interacted.
Be specific.
Long
answer Question on Electronic Reserve Readings "Sweet Success"
from The World that Trade Created by Pomerantz & Topik,
pp. 231 - 233
Read electronic
Reserve Readings "Sweet Success" and then answer the following
question with a brief paragraph in the familiar cl/ev/wa format.
Be sure that your evidence takes the form of direct quotations
of no more than eight words. Obviously, you might
need several quotations to make your point. Without an effective
warrant for your evidence, you will seriously weaken your argument.
9)
According to the author, how and why did Iloila go from being a
"regional competitor" in fabrics to being merely a periphery
in a larger world-system?
(hints: What did Iloila stop
producing? Why? What new type of item did it start consuming? Why?
How and why did these changes together make Iloila a periphery?)
Extra-Credit
(worth up to 33.33 extra points on this homework)
Answer the following question with a brief paragraph in the familiar
cl/ev/wa format. Be sure that your
evidence takes the form of direct quotations of no more than
eight words. Obviously, you might need several quotations
to make your point. Without an effective warrant for your evidence,
you will seriously weaken your argument.
EC)
How did the new economic arrangements on Iloila produce
a negative externality through their impact on social and family
organization?
|